11:1-10
Having established that Israel rejected Jesus, Paul now asks if God rejected his people Israel. By this, he means has God come to a final and absolute rejection of Israel. His answer is no and he sets out to prove it in this chapter.
The first proof is that Paul himself is an Israelite. He is a descendant of Abraham and from the line of Benjamin. And Paul had been both saved and set apart to be an apostle. He was foreknown (set apart before he was born) and called according to God’s purpose. (Galatians 1:15) Therefore, one could not say that God had fully rejected Israel.
In addition, Paul showed how God, in the past, had always saved a remnant. He referred to the story of Elijah. Israel was apostate, worshipping Baal, led by King Ahab and his wife Jezebel, a priestess of Baal from Tyre. She even had prophets of God murdered.
But, when Elijah said he was the only believer left in Israel, God told him he kept a remnant of 7,000 for himself. (4) You can read this story in1 Kings 19.
Likewise,God had saved a remnant during Paul’s time, chosen and saved by grace. (5) And since it was by grace, it was not by works. We see some of these in the gospels. Certainly, the Twelve, minus Judas were Israelites who were saved. Those disciples gathered in the upper room after the crucifixion, Joseph of Arimathea, Nicodemus, John Mark and his mother, Mary Magdalene, Jesus’ mother and brothers, and others were Israelites and were saved.
So, there were two groups of Israelites. The elect Jews were saved. The others were hardened. (7)
Paul returned again to the Old Testament to show this was God’s intention. First, he cited Isaiah 29:10 that God kept them from seeing and hearing. (8) Second, he cited Psalms 69:22, applying it to Jesus again as the stumbling block. (9-10)
Gentiles Brought Into God’s Family
11:11-15
So, God’s purpose was not the full and final rejection of Israel, but a temporary one. The purpose was to bring in the Gentiles. By bringing them into God’s family, Israel might become jealous and turn to Christ. Their rejection of Christ (their trespass) resulted in a blessing to the Gentiles.
Paul himself started his ministry going first to the Jews, then the Gentiles (non-Jews). He preached in the Jewish synagogues. But, he eventually turned to the Gentiles because of the unbelief of the Jews. When he was opposed by Jews in Pisidian Antioch, Paul said:
“It was necessary that the word of God be spoken first to you. Since you thrust it aside and judge yourselves unworthy of eternal life, behold, we are turning to the Gentiles.” (Acts 13:46-47)
Paul even pointed out that this was God’s plan and command, citing Isaiah 49:10: “I have made you a light for the Gentiles, that you may bring salvation to the ends of the earth.”
So, the trespass of the Jews created a blessing for the Gentiles and their full inclusion in the kingdom would mean an even greater blessing. (15)
The Metaphor of the Tree
11:16-24
Paul used a brief metaphor to say that if the dough was holy, the whole lump (ESV, NASB), or batch (NIV) is holy (set apart or sacred) (16). This is a reference to a passage in Numbers where the Lord says that when they eat bread from the crops grown in the land, they are to make a contribution to the Lord in the form of some of the dough. (Numbers 15:17-21)
After that brief thought, Paul switched to the metaphor of a tree and spends quite a bit of time on it. He first said, if the root is holy, so are the branches. (16) The tree represents the whole people of God. There is only one tree, one people. The root is Abraham, the father of all who believe, Jew and Gentile.
Remember Romans 4:11: “The purpose was to make him (Abraham) the father of all who believe…” It is those of faith who are sons of Abraham. (Galatians 3:7)
The branches are the individual people in Israel, the people of God. Some branches of the tree are broken off of the tree. (17) These are unbelieving, works oriented Israelites.
The Gentile believers are wild shoots who are grafted in to the tree of God’s people. They are inserted into the purpose of God’s redeeming grace. They feed on the nourishment of the root. This is the New Covenant. It is the New Covenant fulfilling the Covenant with Abraham, that his seed would be a blessing for peoples\nations.
Apparently, some Gentile believers were arrogant toward the Jews, bragging that unbelieving Jews were broken off from the tree so the Gentile believers could be grafted in. (18) But, that is the wrong attitude. Instead this should magnify the fear of God in them, knowing they would be cut off also if they do not continue in the faith. (21-22) Plus, they should also know that the unbelieving Israelites will be grafted back in if they come to faith in Christ. (23)
Will Israel Be Saved?
11:25-32
Paul now reveals a mystery. In scripture, mystery means a truth that has been hidden in the past but is now revealed.
This mystery is that the hardening of Israel is temporary (partial), lasting until the fullness of the Gentiles has come in. At that point, all Israel will be saved. (25) Paul cites an Old Testament scripture for proof. (26-27) He takes from Isaiah 59:20 and 27:9 and applies it to Christ.
There is a lot of debate and disagreement as to what the statement “all Israel will be saved” means. There are three main theories.
First, some think it means the remnant that is saved during the time between Jesus’ first and second advents (comings). That, however, requires one to believe all and less than all (remnant) are the same. It also does not account for the fact that the Jews turning to Christ only occurs after the number of saved Gentiles becomes “full”.
Second is the idea that Israel here means all believers, Jew (Israelite) and Gentile, throughout history. This requires us to ignore the distinction between Israelites and Gentiles is not being discussed by Paul in the passage, which it clearly is.
Third is the idea that there will be a great turning of Jewish people to Christ toward the end of this age. Reference is made to Revelation 7, where 144,000 from the tribes of Israel are sealed.
While I do not think Revelation 7 is relevant to this issue, I do hold to the third option. I do not believe that every Jewish person, or every person in geographical Israel will be saved, but there will be a great turning to Christ at the end of the age.
Irrevocable Gifts\Unchanging God
11:28-32
Paul acknowledges that the Jews are enemies of God because they have rejected his Son. (28) But, in another sense, they are loved by God for the sake of their forefathers, the patriarchs with whom God made a covenant.
God does not change. So, Paul reasons that his favor (gifts) on Israel and his calling or election of them are irrevocable. All men and women at one time were disobedient to God. God gave mercy to the Gentiles and he will at some point show mercy to the Jews. (32)
Doxology
11:33-36
This truth revealed by Paul leads him to praise. He exalts God for the depth of the riches and the wisdom and knowledge he has. They are so great, we cannot discern them all.
Paul quoted an Old Testament passage extolling the greatness of God to show that men and women cannot know or comprehend the mind of God. (Isaiah 40:13) We must always remember that God is not a better version of ourselves. He is much greater. All things exist from and through him and are for him.
Because he is greater, we must give him glory, as Paul does. (39)